Automakers are aggressively ramping up their efforts to pass a new law outright banning Chinese EVs. They obviously want to do this because they don’t want to compete with better, often significantly cheaper products, but they can’t just say that. Instead, we get a lot of bizarre pretense about how an industry with the worst privacy ratings in America is just super concerned about privacy.
The Alliance for Automotive Innovation (AAI), which represents GM, Toyota, Volkswagen, and other domestic and foreign car makers already doing business in the U.S., are wasting no time in calling for a permanent ban on Chinese EVs after the midterm elections.
The auto industry’s preferred new law, the Connected Vehicle Security Act of 2026, cleared the Senate Commerce Committee in July, and a House version of the bill now has more than 100 co-sponsors. Last September, Senate bill sponsors, Sens. Bernie Moreno (a Republican) and Elissa Slotkin (a Democrat), agreed to delay efforts to fast-track the legislation until this month.
To goad additional lawmakers into action, AAI boss John Bozzella is ramping up the fear mongering in public statements, and routinely brings up privacy and national security concerns as the industry’s primary motivation:
“We need to protect the US market from a flood of Chinese imports that carry surveillance risk and disadvantage current manufacturers that have made generational investments in American communities.”
If there’s going to be rampant unchecked surveillance abuses, they should most assuredly be domestic only, I guess.
This idea that Chinese EVs pose some unique privacy and national security threat to Americans is a common refrain from Bozzella and the auto industry. The argument is that Chinese EVs will collect oceans of data on American consumer driving and behavior habits, then funnel that data back to the Chinese government, who’ll then engage in all manner of ambiguous, nefarious behaviors.
There are several problems with the argument.
The biggest being that these same automakers do a disastrous job securing their own vehicles. Studies repeatedly show that U.S. automakers have some of the worst privacy and security standards in all of tech. An ocean of U.S. consumer driving, behavior, phone, and location data is already hoovered up at scale by your car, often left unencrypted, and sold to a laundry list of dodgy partners (including insurance companies, which will jack up your rates based on your driving habits with no transparency into the process).
The other problem: the U.S. is routinely too corrupt to pass modern internet privacy laws or even competently regulate a vast international web of dodgy data brokers. Most of the data collected by U.S. vehicle makers is already available via these data brokers; who’ll in turn sell this data to literally any random nitwit with two nickels to rub together (including Chinese intelligence).
Failing to secure your own vehicles and fighting tooth and nail against any privacy safeguards… then ranting incoherently about the threat of Chinese tech on U.S. shores is not serious tech policy. Our failure to regulate data brokers or pass modern privacy laws means the Chinese simply buy this same data from any of dozens of dodgy companies already, making a lot of this stuff lazy pantomime.
Unfortunately, this kind of lazy protectionism is a truly bipartisan affair. You saw how Democrats tripped over themselves to help Trump’s billionaire friends steal TikTok under the pretense this would somehow make Americans safer, more secure, and less prone to propaganda.
Democratic lawmakers in Michigan also recently tried to ban Chinese EVs from even visiting the state, suggesting that automakers are afraid of Americans even looking at cheaper overseas alternatives. The justification (by folks who are are, again, completely absent when it comes to any sort of domestic U.S. privacy standards and enforcement) is they were just very concerned about U.S. consumer privacy.
I get the impulse to try and protect U.S. domestic automaker jobs (even though U.S. automakers have a long and detailed history of anti-labor behaviors), but there’s simply no coherent consistency to any U.S. policies. We don’t meaningfully protect labor generally, we don’t enforce consumer protection law, we’re too corrupt to pass a privacy law that reins in data monetization and hyper surveillance, and U.S. policymakers largely pay empty lip service to concepts like “affordability.”
We’ll see how much the new Democratic blood in the House and Senate shifts some of these dynamics, but as it stands now you can expect the new year to be filled with the brim with all sorts of expanded bipartisan xenophobic protectionism across the entirety of tech — from AI to electric vehicles. Ignoring that it will be bumbling Trump zealots like Brendan Carr tasked with a lot of enforcement (see: Carr’s rank incompetence surrounding the Chinese drone ban).
And you can expect all of it to be propped up by bad faith arguments that the bill backers are exclusively, suddenly, and very uncharacteristically concerned about your personal privacy. And in turn propped up by a shitty tech press oddly oblivious to their own nationalism biases.
I maintain that the best path forward is to allow Chinese drones, AI, EVs, vacuums, and assorted other tech into the U.S. market, but properly fund, staff, and legally support our privacy, labor, competition, and consumer protection regulators to ensure a level playing field and healthy markets. Large corporations hate that idea, so instead we get this bizarre and performative protectionist pantomime.